Notes on environment, behavior, creating new systems in this complex world.
Some time ago, I found a small book in a bookstore in Valencia called Frugalidad by Paolo Legrenzi. What stayed with me was the idea of frugality as something deeper than simply spending less.
That little book came back to my mind this week, and I found myself thinking about the life I am living here, in France. A life so different than in New York.
Yes, people here live life less rushed. And, paying attention to everything else other than career achievement allows for less pressured exchanges with others. But it is not just that. I am beginning to see that there are different systems operating underneath the surface.
I have encountered people who organize their lives around different priorities. Organizations created simply to help. A music band whose income isn't the ultimate purpose, but a way of supporting its members' creative projects—composing, designing, throwing a festival. Families who grow different fruits and vegetables and share them with one another. People who carpool or ride bicycles, partly because gasoline is expensive and partly because there is less reason to drive. And people who actually measure the carbon emission of a flight, and choose to make a trip or not based on that!
These examples don't mean that anyone here has escaped capitalism. Of course they haven't. Capitalism reaches almost everywhere: someone makes something, someone sells it, someone profits from it. But the way that people manage in this system, or so I observe, is by living below their means. Not necessarily because they are struggling financially, but because there is little cultural pressure to constantly demonstrate that they have more. I have not heard anyone in the two years that I’ve been here say, “I’ll just put that in my credit card!” in order to justify impulsive spending.
And I keep thinking. Sure, this is a small version of life -the countryside of France- naturally, not all of France, and not all the countryside I assume, but: These ways of living don't appear out of nowhere.
Previous generations built structures that made some of this possible.
A bicycle is easier to choose when a town is built around walking and cycling.
Sharing food becomes natural when families have maintained relationships of reciprocity.
Living with less becomes easier when fewer people around you are constantly signaling that having more means you are doing better.
This is what has fascinated me.
The simplicity is not really about simplicity.
It is about values becoming structures, and structures shaping behavior.
I hardly see the latest cars here.
There may simply be less need for them. But perhaps there is also less need to use an object to communicate something about yourself.
Jean Baudrillard wrote extensively about objects and their sign value—the ways things we purchase can communicate status, identity, belonging, and social position beyond their practical function. His grandparents were farm workers in the french countryside. I find it interesting that I skipped, or forgot, this part of my sociology learning back in college, but that french philosophy has somehow resurfaced on my reading list. Environments have a way of speaking to us.
And then I go into a large city...
Suddenly there are clothes, shoes, restaurants, shops, advertisements, things to want everywhere.
I can feel the difference in my body. The rush in my thoughts. The stimulation.
The sensation of maybe I need this.
The ease with which desire becomes consumption.
Most of us know this feeling.
It is not simply that there are more things available. We have entered an environment that continually asks us to want.
And rarely does the environment ask:
Do you really need this?
Where did it come from?
Who made it?
What did it cost the Earth?
Is this material good for your body?
What does owning this communicate about me?
Who am I trying to become by having it?
I am lucky that I don't have any desire to buy a Lamborghini simply to communicate something about myself to people I don't even know.
But I can still feel it.
That little rush.
The sensation.
The pull toward the object.
And right about then, I noticed that my background in psychotherapy kept entering the conversation in my mind.
Because behavior can change simply because the environment changes.
If there are no shoe stores in your town, you cannot spontaneously buy the latest pair of shoes.
If there isn't a shopping center around the corner, shopping becomes less automatic.
If everyone around you grows food and shares it, you may naturally participate.
The behavior changes by default.
But the desire underneath the behavior may not have changed at all.
The moment you enter a large city—or discover that you can have everything delivered to your door—you may find yourself reaching for your credit card again.
So perhaps changing our behavior requires two things.
We can change the environment that surrounds us.
And we can become curious about what is happening inside us.
Because sometimes the object isn't really the object.
The shoes may be belonging.
The car may be status.
The beautiful handbag may be recognition.
The purchase may be a topic of conversation among friends—a way of gaining social capital, communicating taste, success, or belonging.
And perhaps the rush isn't actually about buying something.
Perhaps we are buying a feeling.
This is where I think psychological awareness can become useful in a conversation about consumption.
Not to shame ourselves for wanting things.
Not to pretend we can step completely outside capitalism.
But to become curious about our desires.
What am I actually looking for when I want this?
What feeling do I imagine this object will give me?
Who do I imagine I will become once I have it?
And is there another way to experience that feeling?
Because we live in many possible worlds on the same planet.
Some are organized more heavily around consumption, individual accumulation, and signaling.
Others make sharing, frugality, repair, reciprocity, and connection easier.
Neither world is perfect.
But living inside a different system for long enough can make the invisible visible.
You begin to notice how much of what you thought was your choice was also shaped by your surroundings.
And perhaps this is where change begins.
Not with deprivation.
Not with guilt.
But with seeing.
And then asking yourself what kind of everyday choices you want to participate in ?